|
Palmer, J. (2001) Motor Automatisms as a Vehicle for ESP Expression Proceedings
of Presented Papers: The Parapsychological Association 44th Annual
Convention (pp. 205-217).
Abstract
This is the latest in a series of experiments exploring ESP as expressed
through motor automatisms, which, if genuine, reflect a dissociative state of
consciousness expected to be psi-conducive. In this experiment, the motor
automatism consisted of hand movements. 40 adult volunteers, most of whom had
previously participated in psi experiments at the Rhine Research Center, served
as "detectors". The target pool consisted of 100 homographs divided
into 20 sets of 5 each. They were selected for diversity of associations in
published normative experiments, and words within each set were equated for
frequency in the English language. A pseudo-random sequence of 100 target words
was stored inside a computer. The detector was seated in front of an alphabet
board modeled after the Ouija board. For up to 30 min, they randomly moved the
pointer around the board in an effort to find letters that appeared in the
target word, recording each letter. An RRC staff member, Cheryl Alexander,
served as sender. The sender's room was located two floors above, but not
directly above, the detector's room. After the detector had gone to their room,
the sender displayed the target word on a computer screen located in a room
adjacent to the sender's room. She then returned to the sender's room to
commence sending. She imagined herself projecting her consciousness into the
detector's room and guiding their hand to the appropriate letters, as well as
directly sending the word and associations to it. While sending, she listened
through stereo headphones to one of two pink-noise tapes, the order of which was
determined by random permutation. The experimental tape contained "binaural
beats" in the theta and delta frequency ranges. Following the reception
period, the detector completed a questionnaire concerning their experience
during the session, and then blind-rated the set of 5 possible targets for
correspondence to the letters they got from the board and from other impressions.
There were 10 direct hits (MCE = 8), which is nonsignificant. Detectors
who said they felt an outside force moving their hand over the board (OF) from
1-40% of the time scored significantly higher than other detectors (p = .0
11). This group (N= 11) had a high mean z-score of .818 (p = 2.4 x 10-5).
Participants had previously completed a 50-item questionnaire consisting of
items from the Complex Partial Epileptic Signs (CPES) scale and the Tellegen
Absorption Scale (TAS). The CPES with the TAS partialled out was considered to
be a trait measure of dissociation and, as predicted, it correlated
significantly with the OF item, considered a state measure of dissociation,
during the session, rp(38) = .756, p = .001. These findings
suggest that moderate levels of dissociation are more psi-conducive than extreme
levels. Finally, there was a suggestive tendency for sessions with the binaural
beat tape to yield higher ESP scores (p = .082), but only for ratings based
exclusively on what came through the board.
|