|
Ganzfeld vs. No Ganzfeld: An Exploratory Study of the Effects of Ganzfeld Conditions on ESP. |
|
|
|
|
escrito por Administrator
|
|
sexta, 10 de setembro de 2004 |
|
da Silva, F. E., Pilato, S. & Hiraoka, R. (2003). Ganzfeld
vs. No Ganzfeld: An Exploratory Study of the Effects of Ganzfeld Conditions on
ESP. Proceedings of Presented Papers: The Parapsychological Association
46th Annual
Convention,(pp. 31-49).
Abstract
In this double-blind exploratory study 74 subjects
participated forming 37 couples (sender/receiver). The sender watched a video
and tried to send it to the receiver, who was located 120 meters away. At the
end of the sending/receiving period (28 min.) the receiver watched four videos
and tried to identify which one had been sent. There were two experimental
conditions. In the Ganzfeld (GZ) condition the researchers and subjects heard a
20-minute relaxation induction. The receiver's eyes were covered with halved
Ping-Pong balls, upon which two red lights were projected, and they listened to
"white noise" during the experimental session. In the non-Ganzfeld (NGZ)
condition, neither the Ping-Pong balls nor the "white noise" were used
and there was no relaxation induction. From July of 2001 to March of 2002, 108
trials (54 GZ and 54 NGZ) were carried out. There was no overall signficance
(hit rate 25,93%), Z=0.11, =0.51. The NGZ and GZ hits (18,52%, Z=-0.94, Tc=-0.41
and 33,33%, Z=1.26, Tc=-0.60 respectively) did not reach significance. However
the GZ hits were in the direction of the findings reported in the Ganzfeld
meta-analysis by Bem and Honorton (1994). The difference between the GZ and NGZ
hits was Significant, p=.0228 one-tailed. We also found that the targets that
were hit were evaluated by receivers (in terms of personal preference and
personal meaning) higher than the targets that were not hit. Analysis of the
qualitative content of hits and misses suggested that in future studies the
qualitative results should be considered along with the conventional methodology
of hits vs. misses. These results seem to be similar to the qualitative findings
found by Parker.
|